I've read almost all of Andrew Greig's novels, which I guess makes me a big fan; in fact, I probably wouldn't have read this if it wasn't by him, not being a big reader of historical fiction. It is quite different to his other novels, but Greig writes on a variety of non-fiction topics (golf, fishing, mountaineering), so why not some variety in his fiction. Greig is a very Scottish writer, this book more than his other fiction, I think.